Ten Reasons to Join a Critique Group

Top Ten Tuesday at Many Little Blessings

I was lucky enough to be invited to join a small local critique group in December.  Last week was the first chance I had to actually meet with them, and it was fabulous! Here’s why:

— 1 —

It’s important to have someone else validate your work.  You know that your writing is important, and that you work hard at it.  Unfortunately, people who don’t write have no way to truly understand this.  So if you’re a blogger, meet with a few other bloggers.  If you write fiction, meet with other people who write fiction.  You don’t have to write the same genre or the same blogging niche to understand each other – sometimes it’s better if you don’t, because it can give you a bit more distance and perspective for your critique.

— 2 —

Meeting in person with a group keeps you accountable.  If you haven’t written in a week why haven’t you written?  Odds are there’s someone else in the group who is busier and more stressed than you are, and has still been writing.  Meeting someone’s eyes and admitting you’ve been catching up on last season’s Downton Abbey instead of writing is completely different than doing so via email.

— 3 —

Fresh sets of eyes catch so many mistakes.  One writer had submitted several pages, and only one of the other three of us caught a completely missing word that was essential to the sentence.  Everyone else had just subconsciously added it as they read.

— 4 —

No one’s grammar or punctuation is perfect.  I’m known for correcting my family’s grammar, but I throw around commas like confetti on New Year’s Eve.  I just can’t help myself.

— 5 —

A good critique group won’t try to change your style of writing, they’ll just help polish it.  They’ll point out awkward phrases, over-used words, and paragraph breaks in the wrong place.

— 6 —

You will take yourself more seriously.  Don’t get me wrong, I’m writing this post in my jammies at 4:30 in the afternoon, but getting dressed, packing up my laptop, and meeting over frou-frou coffee once a week makes me more productive.  It forces me to make my writing a priority.

— 7 —

If you’re home with small children most days, retired, or not working outside your home for whatever reason this is adult social interaction you need for your own mental health.  I’ve always worked full-time, and nearly 100% of my social interaction was work-related in some way.  After my third and fourth neurosurgery, when I was unable to return to work, it became way too easy to never leave the house.  Heck, with a laptop and a good wifi connection I didn’t have to leave the bed!  That’s not good for anyone, no matter what your health status.  If you are physically able, get out there, even if it’s just once a month, somewhere nearby, for an hour.

— 8 —

Try something new.  I’m starting a new book, and I’m going to run every stinkin’ page past my critique group so that hopefully it won’t need to be revised ten times before it’s worth reading.  If you want to try a new genre, start a new meme – these are people who can help.

— 9 —

Constructive criticism is great, and I have made changes in every area that my critique partners mentioned this past week, because I agreed with them.  This will not always be the case.  If you don’t agree that something needs to be changed, don’t change it.  It’s your writing when it comes right down to it.  That said, if more than one person has the exact same criticism give it some weight – especially if you’re part of a small group.

— 10 —

I hope to be able to contribute enough to this group so they’ll want to keep me around for a long time, but not everyone is lucky enough to find the right critique group on the first try.  If I started feeling attacked, if I thought one member was hogging the meeting time every time, or if being late and unprepared was the rule rather than the exception I’d look elsewhere.  Go with your gut.  If you’re looking forward to the meetings it’s probably a good fit (as long as you’re getting something accomplished, not just socializing).  If you find yourself dreading critique day it’s time to move on.

Priced at just $4.99, it is now available in every format your little heart could desire at Smashwords, or, if you prefer, it’s also for sale in a Kindle version at Amazon or a Nook version at Barnes and Noble!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

6 thoughts on “Ten Reasons to Join a Critique Group”

  1. Good for you. My husband and I are retired and we find we go for days without leaving the house or having any kind of social interaction other than between ourselves and our dog. We are trying to get out more.

  2. I used to be part of an online blog portal called blogs4God and it was good to have a variety of people from all parts of historical Christianity (Catholic, Mainline, Reformed, Evangelical, and Orthodox) talking about faith.

  3. (Waving a big flag! Disclaimer: I am part of said critique group.)

    Angie, you have hit so many of the important factors of the whys and hows of critiquing! This group is of vital importance to me: sometimes the only validation I get as an author – and it keeps me accountable; the opportunity to be with other adults outside an occasionally small circle; and it makes me stretch my thinking.

    Thanks for writing about us! And don’t worry; you contribute more than enough. We’ll keep you around!!!

    Now I shall creep off to find a quiet corner so I will have some words to submit next week!

    Leslie, being held accountable 😉

    1. Thanks, Leslie – you are a consistent source of comfort for me, and meeting you is one of the biggest blessings Louisville Romance Writers has brought me. I can’t tell you how honored I was to have you invite me to join the critique group, and I know already our time together will be one of the touchstones of my week 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.